Speculator: We have an E3 ’12 Lightning Round winner!

June 11, 2012

The end of E3 marks the end of the Speculator season around here. We’ll be back with a fresh slate and some tweaks in two weeks, but check out how we did at E3 after the break, including a tightly-contested Lightning Round.

At Microsoft’s event

Microsoft scores: Andrew 207, Eric 90, Graham 194, Shawn 50

New console shown or teased – NO
Andrew 1%, Eric 5%, Graham 5%, Shawn 20%

Kinect game from Epic – NO
Andrew 1%, Eric 25%, Graham 5%, Shawn 15%

Dance Central 3 – YES
Andrew 20%Eric 75%Graham 10%, Shawn 15%

Kinect Sports: Season 3 – NO
Andrew 55%, Eric 75%, Graham 60%, Shawn 70%

Any new first-party IP – YES (Ed.: Technically, Twisted Pixel’s LocoCycle counts.)
Andrew 10%, Eric 0%, Graham 5%Shawn 55%

Another Dashboard refresh – NO
Andrew 45%, Eric 65%Graham 40%Shawn 75%

“Hey guys, we paid Activision to get timed exclusivity on Call of Duty DLC again!” – YES
Andrew 90%, Eric 100%, Graham 100%, Shawn 100%

Appearances?

Gabe Newell – NOAndrew 1%, Eric 0%, Graham 1%, Shawn 5%

Cliff Bleszinski – NO: Andrew 50%, Eric 100%, Graham 95%, Shawn 95%

Hideo Kojima – NOAndrew 10%, Eric 50%, Graham 10%Shawn 65%

Any indie developer – NOAndrew 5%Eric 75%Graham 5%, Shawn 85%

A non-games celebrity – YESAndrew 55%, Eric 100%, Graham 100%, Shawn 100%

 

At Sony’s event

Sony scores: Andrew 281, Eric -57, Graham 165, Shawn 253

New console shown or teased –NO
Andrew 1%Eric 65%, Graham 20%, Shawn 0%

The Last Guardian – NO
Andrew 1%, Eric 40%, Graham 50%, Shawn 15%

Vita price drop – NO
Andrew 40%, Eric 35%, Graham 50%, Shawn 55%

PS1 Classics playable on Vita – YES
Andrew 30%, Eric 75%, Graham 50%, Shawn 85%

Any new first-party retail Move game – YES
Andrew 55%Eric 5%, Graham 20%, Shawn 15%

PS3 price drop – NO
Andrew 80%, Eric 75%, Graham 50%, Shawn 60%

“Hey guys, we’re still really sorry about that PSN downtime thing!” – NO
Andrew 1%Eric 60%Graham 0%, Shawn 45%

Appearances?

Kaz Hirai – YESAndrew 90%, Eric 75%, Graham 95%, Shawn 90%

Kevin Butler – NOAndrew 30%Eric 100%, Graham 70%, Shawn 40%

Cliff Bleszinski – NOAndrew 10%Eric 100%Graham 5%, Shawn 15%

Anyone from Bungie – NOAndrew 20%, Eric 0%, Graham 15%, Shawn 5%

Someone in a Sackboy costume – NOAndrew 1%, Eric 37%, Graham 40%, Shawn 22%

 

At Nintendo’s event

Nintendo scores: Andrew 260, Eric 61, Graham 435, Shawn 315

Wii U dated – NO

Andrew 50%, Eric 100%, Graham 10%, Shawn 25%

Wii U priced – NO
Andrew 30%Eric 100%Graham 10%, Shawn 15%

Multiple screen controllers, one system – YES
Andrew 75%, Eric 80%, Graham 50%, Shawn 90%

Pikmin 3 – YES
Andrew 95%Eric 25%, Graham 85%, Shawn 90%

Paper Mario 3DS – YES
Andrew 85%, Eric 100%, Graham 95%, Shawn 90%

New 3DS model – NO
Andrew 5%, Eric 30%, Graham 5%, Shawn 40%

“Hey guys, Pandora’s Tower is getting localized!” – NO
Andrew 55%, Eric 65%Graham 10%Shawn 70%

Appearances?

Hideo Kojima – NOAndrew 15%, Eric 40%, Graham 10%, Shawn 30%

Shigeru Miyamoto – YESAndrew 85%, Eric 100%, Graham 100%, Shawn 100%

Cliff Bleszinski – NOAndrew 5%, Eric 0%, Graham 5%, Shawn 0%

Anyone from Valve, Bungie, Respawn or Insomniac – NO: Andrew 50%, Eric 0%, Graham 40%, Shawn 50%

Uggie – NOAndrew 60%, Eric 99%Graham 5%, Shawn 25%

 

Final Lightning Round scores:

Graham Russell: 794
Andrew Passafiume:
748
Shawn Vermette: 618
Eric Albuen: 94

 

Prior Results

Epic Mickey 2 in the works at Disney – YES: Andrew 70%, Graham 80%, Shawn 75%

3DS Slide Pad coming to US in 2012 – YES: Andrew 80%, Graham 80%, Shawn 80%

‘Xbox Next’ to be revealed by E3 2012 – NO: Andrew 85%, Graham 60%, Shawn 85%, Eric 30%

Medal of Honor 2 coming in 2012 – YES: Andrew 95%, Graham 81%, Shawn 80%, Eric 70%

Need for Speed 13 to be announced by E3 2012 – YES: Andrew 95%, Graham 87%, Shawn 90%, Eric 80%

The Last of Us to release in 2012 – NO: Andrew 95%, Graham 55%, Shawn 65%, Eric 25%

Sony to announce God of War 4 by E3 2012- YES: Andrew 80%, Graham 55%, Shawn 90%, Eric 95%

L. A. Noire follow-up to be announced by E3 2012- NO: Andrew 20%, Graham 5%, Shawn 10%

New Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles game to be announced by E3 – NO: Andrew 70%, Graham 80%, Shawn 80%

Next Splinter Cell game to be a series reboot- YES: Andrew 70%, Graham 60%, Shawn 35%, Eric 45%

Blizzard to unveil its new MMO, Project Titan, by E3 2012 – NO: Andrew 5%, Graham 1%, Shawn 50%, Eric 45%

Microsoft to release a cheaper 360 with required Live in 2012- YES: Andrew 60%, Graham 95%, Shawn 75%, Eric 75%

 

Final Season Results and Winner

Graham Russell: 1930
Andrew Passafiume: 1653
Shawn Vermette: 1283
Eric Albuen: 239

Join us next time as we start a new season of Speculator!